|
- Readme First! - Read and follow the rules, otherwise your posts will be closed |
|
|
|
|
|
There are currently, 549 guest(s) and 0 member(s) that are online.
You are Anonymous user. You can register for free by clicking here |
|
|
|
|
|
| The comments are owned by the poster. We aren't responsible for their content. |
| | | | |
No Comments Allowed for Anonymous, please register | | | | |
Re: PHP-Nuke and Xaraya by Gregory Remington (Score: 1) by Zhen-Xjell on Tuesday, February 18 @ 23:52:56 CET (User Info | Send a Message) http://castlecops.com | Very interesting and thanks for sharing. Your demo system looks very promising. Especially the LDAP authentication that will go a long way in a corporate LDAP environment. I notice that the alpha phase isn't supported in a production environment. What is your timeline for beta and gold? |
| Parent | | | | |
Re: PHP-Nuke and Xaraya by Gregory Remington (Score: 0) by Anonymous on Wednesday, February 19 @ 01:34:54 CET | Gregory,
Gregory, you must be a marketing guy ;-) You sounds like one.
Be fair. You compare *.Nuke system with the IBMs, MS' Documentums, Interwovens of this world (Portal and CMS products).
Neither PhpNuke nor PostNuke nor Xaraya can directly compete with these commercial apps and never will or can. *.Nuke system are for small and mid size companies and communities. The maintenance of ALL *.Nuke is a nightmare. The requirements for large companies a fairly larger than *.Nuke could ever fulfil. If you think Xaraya could compete with them, you're dreaming. Have you ever run a *.Nuke site with >50000 existing, active users with >1000000 content items, >1000000 hits per day? I guess, NO. It's an architectural problem that can not be solved without a COMPLETE rework and that would definitily lead to backward incompatibilities. We all can either stick with it and live or make the best with the limitations or start from the ground up with something new. I personally stick with *.Nuke because i know how hard it is to compete with larger commercial apps.
Well, and LDAP ... that's only one of the more important requirements (here topic system integration) of many for corporates.
BTW, Xaraya is on a good way and i will look at it from to time to time. Really nice work and good ideas. But finnally, only time will show, if all features will ever come and(!) work. Maybe Xaraya could become a real success, then.
Cheers,
Andreas Stratmann |
| Parent | | | | | |